| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • You already know Dokkio is an AI-powered assistant to organize & manage your digital files & messages. Very soon, Dokkio will support Outlook as well as One Drive. Check it out today!

View
 

Culture: On Gender Mores

Page history last edited by MissMaddy 15 years, 6 months ago

The Realm is a matriarchy, as is the majority of Creation. For the most part, the legendary rulers of Creation... Merlinda, and after her, several Shoguns and the of course the mighty Scarlet Empress... have been female. Does that mean that women are all ripped bodybuilders, chugging down beers, while petite and effeminate menfolk tend the kitchens and raise the young? Not exactly! This article is meant to clarify exactly what gender means for people in the world of Exalted.

 

This article primarily applies to the Realm, but many other areas of Creation pattern themselves from the expectation of the First Age 'Mother Culture', so matriarchal government in relatively common. In particular, Greyfalls is strongly influenced by the Culture of the Realm and aspires to mirror it in most circumstances.

 

Sexism usually involves a magnification of negative traits while a similar magnification of positive traits take place simultaneously. Gender roles don't really reverse, in Exalted, or even particularly change. Cultures just place different value upon various character traits which are already innate to the two sexes.

For example, let's take a paragon of our culture - the stereotypical 'Jock'. Think marine, or football player. In our culture, he can embody many virtues. He is Brave, Strong, Fierce, and Competitive.

 

In Greyfalls, it's not that women occupy this role (though of course some women might). It's that the man is judged more harshly. He might be considered foolish instead of brave... brutish instead of strong... bloodthirsty instead of fierce... or an immature glory-hound instead of competitive.

 

Both cultures are looking at the same individual. They just value (or devalue) them in a different fashion.

 

Sexist 'common knowledge' probably focuses upon negative masculine traits which are magnified to become attributed to all men... just like, in our culture, all blonde women are often perceived by sexists as being stupid.

 

ALL men probably drink too much. ALL men think with the brain located in their groin. ALL men can be distracted too easily by rage, or sex, or vendetta. They ultimately never achieve the emotional maturity that women do. The male mind just can't quite do it. They are always eternal teenagers.

 

Meanwhile, women are viewed through a similarly distorted lens. Women are usually quicker than men, being smaller, thus they are superior in the martial arts. Women are generally more clever, in subjects such as art and mathematics. Women understand temperance to a greater degree. Women truly understand responsibility, being tied to the family structure in such an intimate way through childbirth. Women are superior artists, because they have patience and dedication. Women are superior leaders, because they are more intuitive and ruthless. Women are loyal, and society accepts female promiscuity as a harmless 'wandering heart'; men are sluts, and society views a promiscuous male as they might view a stupid dog which humps any leg that comes near, driven only by base instinct.

 

The Scarlet Empress is a great example of all of the 'female' virtues that Greyfalls probably values.

 

If you want an evenheaded, qualified individual to lead your army or construction project... common knowledge suggests you want a woman. Men can handle complicated tasks, certainly, but in the end the 'Male Nature' will shine through and you'll find your foreman screwing some of the help or coming to work drunk one day. You asked for it!

 

Outside of the Realm and Greyfalls, attitude vary considerably, but unlike our 'real world'... where anthropological records reveal that ninety-nine percent of all ancient cultures were patriarchal in nature... a slight majority of cultures in Exalted pattern themselves on the ancient ideal of female-to-female property inheritance. In many of these places, the passage of time has altered cultural expectation from the First Age 'norm' into a myriad of confusing customs and behaviours. In other regions, where conditions are too harsh to allow otherwise, sexism can almost vanish... often replaced by pragmatic expectation of the 'ownership' of the household tasks required to eke out existance. Strongly sexist patriarchies exist as well, but they are somewhat rare, owing to the fairly recent example of the Empress (One of the few worldwide personas of this age). Most of these cultures are Western or Southern, though the Scavenger Lands is cosmopolitan enough to have a few unusual communities that believe in this way as well.

 

Comments (6)

Ayesha said

at 3:44 am on Oct 24, 2008

The Delzahn that rule Chiaroscuro are also very strongly patriarchal. Now that I think about it the rulers of the most important cities of the south are all male. The Tri-Khan of Chiaroscuro, the Perfect of Paragon and the Despot of Gem are male. The books (at least A Shadow over Heavens Eye) also depict the Varang city states as patriarchal. Harborhead, on the other hand, seems matriarchal.

The East is mentioned as majoritarily matriarchal, but I wonder if the armies of the 100K are formed by females, equalitarian or predominantly made up of "brutish" males. :)

Richard Hughes said

at 3:50 am on Oct 24, 2008

The patriarchalism of the South and the Delzhan stems at least in part from the wide influence of Tamuz, a powerful first-age Lunar whose terrible memories of his domineering solar mate Chiara led to a pretty deep-set misogynistic streak.

You can be confident that most armies everywhere are formed predominantly of men. Whatever their vices, men are bigger and stronger and testosterone-er, and in war, that's handy.

wastevens@... said

at 5:17 am on Oct 24, 2008

"ALL men probably drink too much. ALL men think with the brain located in their groin. ALL men can be distracted too easily by rage, or sex, or vendetta. They ultimately never achieve the emotional maturity that women do. The male mind just can't quite do it. They are always eternal teenagers."

I'm not sure I'd agree with this bit. You seem to be arguing that western sterotypes about gender contain a fundamental truth, and that the only way in which they are varied is by the emphasis placed on the positive vs negative elements. But even some of those 'understood' truths (esp. regarding male vs female sex drives) are relatively recent- you don't have to look far back in fiction to find where it was women who constantly tried to seduce men, or in papers where it was simply understood that women were raging balls of sexual need, compared to men who would 'dole it out'. (Even some efforts at subverting this end up reinforcing it to a degree- take the Aristophane's play Lysistrata, where the woman refuse to sleep with the men of a town until they quit their warmongering. One of the constant challenges the leader of the strike has is keeping the women from sneaking back to the men at night.)

Which isn't to say that emphasizing/de-emphasizing style isn't also workable. But it seems to contain an embedded assumption of truth in the sterotypes it aimed at.

Ayesha said

at 11:12 am on Oct 24, 2008

I think MissMady meant examples of what is said about males in Matriarchal societies. Those stereotypes are usually false, like all stereotypes. However, cultural pressure might force males in Matriarchal societies to behave like that, after all, they are expected to be like that anyway, so such behaviour is tolerated and even subtly encouraged.

wastevens@... said

at 11:29 am on Oct 24, 2008

Right, I got that. My counterpoint was that those examples are modern western sterotypes with the emphasis shifted around slightly, and that there's no inherent reason why it would be unreasonable for a matricarchal society to have radically different gender expectations.

Like, the idea of men (especially unmarried men) as being perpetual teenagers, incapable of either caring well for themselves and immersed in irresponcibility- unwilling to 'grow up' is one more rooted in 90s sitcoms than any literary tradition. So, I see no reason to transport it to the Realm.

Now, for purposes of actual play, that might also be the most expedient approach to take- it's easily understood and not any more wrong than any other disertation on the ramifications of fictional history on fictional culture. My point was to raise wither we wanted to use reversed western gender sterotypes, or if they had just been assumed as a default baseline.

Saffron Horizon said

at 10:59 am on Dec 12, 2008

Honestly, I would probably say that most non-exalted cultures, meaning those associated closely with the realm, or were not founded post-contagion by an exalt or other magical being would be mostly Patriarchal. The thing about exaltation is that at the levels it ascends a person to, any real or perceived difference in the sexes becomes insignificant, allowing either gender to gain the reigns of power and start a cultural standard.

Also, most matriarchal societies in exalted seem to follow the general pattern of lady at the top, men at all the high-ranking official positions, with women in the lower-ranking commander-ish positions or powerful non-official positions, with the rank-and-file of the nobility being of mixed gender.

You don't have permission to comment on this page.